Skip to main content

NOW ACCEPTING SUBMISSIONS FOR THE 8TH ANNUAL PRINTMAKING JURIED EXHIBITION.

Idaherma Blog

close-up-person
By: evanwconsl

Mezzotint Vs. Etching Vs. Engraving: Intaglio Techniques Compared

Key Takeaways  :

  • Mezzotint, etching, and engraving are all intaglio printing methods, but each creates an image in a totally different way.  
  • Mezzotint begins with black ink and works its way down to white by using a rocker to create deep tones.  
  • The process of etching uses acid to etch lines on a plate, whereas engraving uses a pointed burin.  
  • Museums can identify such prints based on their lines, burr, and tonal range when viewed under magnification.  
  • The method one chooses will depend upon the type of image one wishes to create.  

  

Looking at a classic print and trying to understand just how it was made is one of those experiences collectors and students share with many other curious art fans. It looks as if someone drew it by hand, but there is something photo-like about the shading, and all that the label says is "intaglio print".   

This one-word description covers three different techniques, which have their own instruments, past, and unique characteristics.   

So, recognizing them requires much more than just looking; one needs to know what to recognize.   

Here we will describe Mezzotint vs etching and engraving so that when you employ these techniques, you are not in any confusion.   

Table of Contents  :

  1. What Is Engraving?  
  2. What Is Etching?  
  3. What Is Mezzotint Printmaking?  
  4. Mezzotint vs Etching vs Engraving: Key Differences  
  5. How Do Museums Distinguish Mezzotints From Engravings?  
  6. Which Intaglio Technique Should You Choose?  
  7. Three Techniques, One Craft  
  8. FAQs  

1) What Is Engraving?             

dd

Engraving is the oldest intaglio printmaking technique of the three, having originated in the 15th century.   

The process involves using an artist's sharp steel tool known as the burin and making cuts on a copper plate. The precision of each line is so high that any mistakes are avoided because all the lines are manually carved out.   

To learn more about this technique, see how a mezzotint print came into being as a response to engraving.  

2) What Is Etching?              

dd

In etching, there is a change from muscle work to chemical work.   

The plate is first covered with a layer of wax ground, which is scratched using a needle so as to reveal the metal underneath. The acid bites on the revealed areas depending on the duration that the plate stays immersed in the acid.   

Compared to engraving, etching allows for a more relaxed technique because the needle moves more easily on the wax than the burin on the copper.  

3) What Is Mezzotint Printmaking?                    

printmaking

Mezzotint inverts the whole process.While the other techniques begin with an untouched plate and proceed with etching and biting, the mezzotint process begins with roughing up the whole plate with a rocker – a serrated curved blade. When printed at that stage, the plate produces a solid black. Next, the artist proceeds with a reverse technique – they scrape and burn away parts of the roughed plate to let light through.This is precisely the answer to the question- how are mezzotints made – an image is created out of darkness.This is the reason why mezzotints are so efficient in capturing smooth transitions and painting techniques, and why they were considered the best technique for portrait reproduction in the 17th and 18th centuries.

4) Mezzotint vs Etching vs Engraving: Key Differences : 

Looking at the three together makes the difference easier to take in.                

difference

It’s clear from the table that the true division is between tone and line.In engraving and etching, the picture is formed by lines, but in Mezzotint, by tones of light. Even the restoration of older mezzotints is a delicate operation that requires a lot of insight by smart handlers. The analysis of the 19th-century Mezzotint with foxing that was conducted through enhanced washing and scanning XRF analysis in 2026 is an example of how advanced methods can be used to treat artworks without damaging paper prints.  

5) How Do Museums Distinguish Mezzotints from Engravings?

It is a question that conservators keep asking, and that is: how do museums distinguish between mezzotints and engravings? This is through visual observation.Engravings have clean and continuous lines under magnification because each one of them was carved into a plate using only one line. Conversely, mezzotints have a granular and even velvety appearance with no lines whatsoever, but just a smooth transition from black to white. A 2023 identification guide for antique prints states that a smooth transition from light to dark, along with a softer appearance in general, serves as the most clear-cut sign that a certain piece is not an engraving or etching, but a mezzotint. Conservators shed more light on this matter. 

6) Which Intaglio Technique Should You Choose?                    

intaglio

Those who prefer a more adventurous approach should try etching, which is fast thanks to acid doing the hard work. In contrast, engraving requires great precision and patience for creating a permanent line.  For readers interested in other techniques, similar in tonal qualities and texture, there is the Collagraph Technique, which demonstrates how fabric and paper layers are inked in the same way as a metal plate. The embossed prints created by layered plates vary in quality every time the artist pulls the print.   

close-up

If you need more knowledge on Mezzotints or which Intaglio techniques one must hone their skills on, then the Invited Artists page is dedicated to the artists invited to demonstrate the printmaking process. This is where the mezzotintist and burin engraver reveal the secrets of their craft.  

ff

7) Three Techniques, One Craft :

Mezzotint, etching, and engraving are three methods that work completely differently in solving the very same problem of transferring an image to paper. The method of engraving involves carving, etching means dissolving, and Mezzotint is about taking light away from darkness.  

After learning what it takes to tell them apart, they cease to be a riddle and become a visual language. It would be impossible to create the best guide to intaglio printmaking without learning them.   

If you are interested in learning more about the various printmaking techniques discussed in this blog, then we invite you to browse through our Mezzotint-based webpage and start reading more about the same.

8) FAQs :

  • What is the primary characteristic that sets Mezzotint apart from etching and engraving?  

    Engraving creates lines through cutting; etching uses acid to create lines; while Mezzotint uses texture removed from a blackened plate to create tone.  

  • How are mezzotints created using a rocker?  

    The serrated edge of the rocker tool is moved across the plate to create an ink-holding burr.  

  • What makes Mezzotint better at producing black tones than etching and engraving?  

    Because it starts with a black background, there is much more ink that can be held in the plate.  

  • Which of the intaglio processes is best for portrait prints?  

    Mezzotint is the best process for portraits because of its ability to create tonal variations similar to painting.  

  • Are mezzotint, etching, and engraving compatible processes?  

    These processes can all be used in conjunction on the same plate.  

Read More
banner of blog
By: evanwconsl

July 2019

Last month the Idaherma Museum of Art Foundation, Inc. awarded two prizes in honor of David Latin Williams.   One was at the Philadelphia Sketch Club Teen Arts Show.  The second was at the Philadelphia Plastic Club in the Medals Show. 

 

We also received a new CD of Artwork from one of our currently Invited Artists, Carol Fitz Simmons.  The photo of her work in included here.  If you would like to be featured on 
The Ida, please submit your artwork to our upcoming juried show.  The rules are here. and our brochure is available online.

 

See No
See No, Photopolymer Aquatint, Chine' Colle', Linen Thread 2019, Carol FitzSimonds
Eyes
Eyes, Photopolymer Aquatint, Chine' Colle', 2019, Carol FitzSimonds

 

Read More
banner of blog
By: evanwconsl

March

March with its blistery winds and snowy days bring new art to The Ida.  It is refreshing and cooling and forecast of things to come.  So look at the entries and see how March will end. with a fresh beginning.  Mr. Pitt, Mr. Sostre and Ms. Tarentino all contribute with their new ideas in the beginning growth of The Ida.  Let the winds roll and end in sun!

Read More
banner of blog
By: evanwconsl

Welcoming our New Artists

The Idaherma Museum of Art Foundation, Inc. is dedicating to finding new artists.  We have our mission statement yet sometimes artists respond to their own mission as is the case with our 1st prize winner, Mr. Adam Pitt.  Is he a mirror of society?  In looking at his work, we can only say "Yes!" The Ida will continue to search and find unique talent and we hope that our work will mirror the majestic beauty in our world, inside and outside.  We are all one and though we follow different paths, all paths lead to new and different themes and artists will follow their own unique vision.  We welcome our new artists.

Read More
banner of blog
By: evanwconsl

February 2019

This past January ended the first online entries for our first exhibition and awards.  We are honored to present to the first prize of $200 to Adam Pitt. His work is a reminder of the freshness and qualities that a new vision can bring to the world.  This work shows a spark of originality and is just a beginning, for growth starts in that way.  The second prize goes to Mario Sostre for his work in still life.  The third prize goes to works on paper by Leigh Tarentino.

This begins the first exhibition.  We will post the results more formally and notify the artists shortly.

Stay tuned for the next invitational show.

Read More